Age is the first factor. If your roof is over 20 years old and you’re dealing with multiple problem areas, replacement usually makes more economic sense than ongoing repairs. But age alone doesn’t determine everything. The extent and type of damage matter more. Isolated storm damage, a few missing shingles, or localized leaks can typically be repaired effectively. But if you have widespread granule loss, multiple leak points, or structural damage from ice dams or fallen trees, replacement might be your better option. We’ll give you an honest assessment. Sometimes homeowners expect us to push them toward the more expensive option, but that’s not how we work. If a repair will solve your problem for years to come, that’s what we’ll recommend. If you’re going to be calling us back every season, we’ll tell you that too.